Not so Good Friday
March 21, 2008 — DarcsFalconGrowing up in a Christian (not Catholic) school, Good Friday was a day off. We didn’t have Spring vacation, we had Easter vacation. Easter, in the Christian community, is considered the Holiest day of all, the day Christ rose from the dead. As a child, I never understood why the Friday before Easter was called “good,” if that was the day Christ was executed. What could be good about that? As an adult, I understand the good that came from His death and resurrection. I also no longer believe that the slaying of Christ occurred on a Friday.
I was taught that the Crucifixion took place on the day before Sabbath, and since the Sabbath takes place beginning at sundown on Friday, that meant Christ died on Friday afternoon. Math was taught at my school, and for the life of me, I just couldn’t get Friday night and Saturday night to add up to three nights in the tomb. (Matt. 12:40 for just as JONAH WAS THREE DAYS AND THREE NIGHTS IN THE BELLY OF THE SEA MONSTER, so will the Son of Man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.) Jesus Himself said that, and I knew He wasn’t confused about how long He’d be dead. Were the grown-ups wrong, I wondered? Was that even possible, all these people who knew more than me? Yes, I was pretty naive. Logic and common sense told me that He would have to have been crucified on Thursday, period. But, if He was placed in the tomb just before the start of the Sabbath, which occurred at sundown Friday, where was the missing day? Confusing, no? What happened between Thursday afternoon, and Friday’s sundown? It took me many years, but I found out.
(Num 28:16 ‘Then on the fourteenth day of the first month shall be the LORD’S Passover.) (Lev. 23:5 ‘In the first month, on the fourteenth day of the month at twilight is the LORD’S Passover.) [The first month of the Jewish calendar is now called Nisan.]
The Passover was a Special Sabbath. It was to take place on the 14th day of the 1st month. So, if the 14th of Nisan occurred on a Wednesday at sundown, you would have a special Wednesday Sabbath, then the Feast of Unleavened Bread takes place on Thursday the 15th, and then there was the standard Sabbath at sundown on Friday. We know Christ ate the Passover supper, and later that night he was arrested and put on trial. We know the following day he was crucified, and that He died before sundown - which would have been the 15th, the day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread. (Num. 28: 17 ‘On the fifteenth day of this month shall be a feast, unleavened bread shall be eaten for seven days.) (Lev. 23:6 ‘Then on the fifteenth day of the same month there is the Feast of Unleavened Bread to the LORD; for seven days you shall eat unleavened bread.) So, He had to be buried before the Feast began, Thursday. It all fits nicely now. I don’t know why I was taught that Passover had to have occurred at sundown on Friday. In Jewish custom, if Passover falls on the regular Sabbath, it is moved up 2 days. To Wednesday. It’s important to note that the special-ness of this Sabbath is mentioned in Scripture. (Jn. 19:31a Then the Jews, because it was the day of preparation, so that the bodies would not remain on the cross on the Sabbath (for that Sabbath was a high day),) It wasn’t just your ordinary Friday Sabbath, it was a Special Sabbath during the middle of the week.
I know, I know, what difference does all this make anyway? For me, it matters because I believe it’s important - no, critical - to know why we believe what we believe. Growing up, the most frequent answer I received for most questions I had was “You just have to have faith,” or “That’s just what we believe.” I am firmly convinced that if we don’t question our beliefs, and find answers for them, then it’s all too easy to be led like sheep and fall for anything that sounds good, or feels good. I never wanted to simply be a follower. I wanted to know what I was following and why. In reality, it’s not that important what day Christ was crucified on, it’s important simply that He was crucified, that He died, and rose from the dead. But I couldn’t get past the Friday-Sunday thing somehow equaling 3 days and nights, so I had to find the answer to the question I had. I never really did buy the Friday thing - now I know why.
Holidays and observances in Nisan
- 14 Nisan - Fast of the Firstborn - on 12 Nisan when the 14th falls on Shabbat
Holiday observances
In Israel, Passover lasts for seven days with the first and last days being major holidays. In Orthodox and Conservative communities, no work is performed and most of the observances of Shabbat are adhered to. A Seder is held on the first day.
Pesach — Passover
-
Main article: Passover
- Erev Pesach and Fast of the Firstborn known as “Ta’anit Bechorim” — 14 Nisan
- Passover/Pesach (פסח) (first two days) — 15 (and 16) Nisan
- The “Last days of Passover”, known as Acharon shel Pesach, are also a holiday commemorating K’riat Yam Suf, the Passage of the Red Sea. — 21 (and 22) Nisan
- The semi-holiday days between the “first days” and the “last days” of Passover are known as Chol Hamo’ed, referred to as the “Intermediate days”.
Pesach (Passover) commemorates the liberation of the Israelite slaves from Egypt. No leavened food is eaten during the week of Pesach, in commemoration of the fact that the Jews left Egypt so quickly that their bread did not have enough time to rise.
The first seder begins at sundown on the 15th of Nisan, and the second seder is held on the night of the 16th of Nisan. On the second night, Jews start counting the omer. The counting of the omer is a count of the days from the time they left Egypt until the time they arrived at Mount Sinai.



http://sjthunder.deviantart.com




March 21, 2008 at 9:12 am
“the day before Sabbath” to me sounds like the calendar day before, i.e. Thursday. Should I be reading that “daytime”?
March 21, 2008 at 11:34 am
Right, because the Sabbath begins at sundown Friday, so the day before Sabbath would be Friday between sunrise and sundown.
The Jewish calendar is lunar based, and it gets confusing sometimes.
March 21, 2008 at 11:59 am
I remember these long, drawn-out discussion early in your career as a dispensationalist and apologist. This one stuck in your craw almost as much as 1 Cor 1:10.
I love seeing your growth. Now you have become the master, and I the learner. Wonderful information, settling the matter for good.
May 12, 2008 at 7:20 pm
I’ve really grown to appreciate other Christian denominations lately. America would really be nothing without them. I’ve realized that every country that is run by a majority of Catholics, which I am, is just a third world country praying for a better future. If you think I’m joking, there is a lot of data to back this up. I’m not saying Catholics are bad, but they are caught up in the dogma rather than reality. And I believe that what makes America great, is out hope for the future– something many countries don’t have
I’m also weary and questioning of a lot of denominations like you are. I like a lot of the older straight forward ones that split form the Roman Church, particularly Lutherans, because they started with the idea that Christians don’t need to be reliant on a hierarchy of dark figures. You know, how about priests can get married?– that seems like a good idea. The Catholic Church will never except this, after all, what is the hierarchy suppose to do with all those children of priests and they could become like a kingdom based on nepotism. Catholic priests and nuns have made a huge sacrifice– to be alone with no one but God.
Roman Catholics band together, at least Chicago ones do. Leaving Chicago for good is simply out of the question for many of them, including my family. My father’s side has been in Chicago since there were corn fields in the city, probably for well over 130 years. I guess its because the religion is tied to ethics who came off the boat– they band together too.
May 12, 2008 at 9:47 pm
Well, I guess I can’t really say I questioned a lot of denominations per se. I questioned the one I was raised in (Baptist), and while on many doctrinal issues I still agree with it, I found I disagreed with a lot of the attitude I found in it. IMHO, the only thing that matters in matters of faith, is Truth, and I believe there is only one place to find it, and that is the Bible. What religion would you be if you read just the Bible? Can you be Catholic without the addition of catechism? Can you be Mormon without also reading the Book of Mormon? Can you be a Jehovah’s Witness if you don’t read all their extra material? The Bible doesn’t need any help, it stands alone. I no longer consider myself Baptist. I do think of myself as a Dispensational Apologist, although not a very good one! And if you ever would like to discuss religious things, believe me, I would be more than happy to talk about it with you.
As to your family leaving Chicago - well you could always ask them this: Did not their families leave the lands of their births and come to America? Were they not brave enough to seek a new life far from home where nothing was familiar? Does not the blood of those ancestors run in their veins, and give them the same courage? If those distant relatives were fearless enough to leave Italy and sail the seas, so too your family could leave Chicago and drive the highways to find a new city in which to build a better life as well.
Now if we could just get companies to pay moving expenses!
May 12, 2008 at 11:35 pm
I agree with what you say and I was almost going to mention in this post what I tell people– my ancestors didn’t flee Europe to be dependent on Rome. This is true.
I agree people need religion and I’d rather have faith in some god over any atheism– atheism is despair and depressingly mechanical, although not always.
But I mean this is America! We can make things work, I’d say most of my family is Catholic in civic duty primarily– the dogma is like “ok let’s believe this and we have each other.” I’ve grown beyond challenging certain things and excepting them as civic responsibility, although i don’t always admit it.
The real pain of any religion is when people take it out of context and use it against others. I don’t know, I really wasn’t all that thrilled when people were cheering the Pope all throughout America (he didn’t bother to stop in Chicago by the way). It is like didn’t we come over here to escape this? Fine you may personally be an alright guy, but here our founders were masons and deists– I don’t know this country was founded to escape people in white robes and golden chains.
So yeah, I don’t know maybe my view is narrow minded and i’d love for you to challenge me on it! The Bible is a very good book of wisdom and there is a lot of truth in it– I’m still weary of it. It is really primarily a Jewish text, at least the old testament– which claims the Jews are the “chosen people” and I don’t believe anyone is chosen–people choose themselves! I’m no better than a starving child in Africa neither is anyone else.
May 12, 2008 at 11:42 pm
Oh thanks for the zoom picture– you know I don’t hate Chicago–it is home– and I don’t know if I can culturally escape it — physically too.
May 15, 2008 at 12:31 am
JR - It’s hard to explain, but I’m getting this “vibe” from you, for lack of a better term. You seem to be in a place in your life where you’re evaluating everything you’ve ever known.
I suspect your hatred of Chicago stems from your love of it. Your eyes were opened when you left, and now that hurts. No? It was home, and now it’s not, and that’s painful.
As for the religion thing, I might be able to help you with that, if you’re sincere about looking. But that would be better done in email than on a blog. You have my email if you’d like to talk further about that, or if you have questions about Biblical things, or religious things. Um, no, I wouldn’t “preach” at you, that’s NOT my style and I don’t like it when people try to do it to me either. I can only share with you what I know, and you can judge for yourself if you agree or not. So, the offer’s there if you’re interested. If not, that’s cool too.
No pressure.